  Cyle Larin | Canadá | 6 |
 Jonathan David | Canadá | 5 |
 Christian Pulisic | Milán | 4 |
  Rolando Blackburn | Panamá | 4 |
  Michail Antonio | Jamaica | 3 |
  Raúl Jiménez | México | 3 |
 Ricardo Pepi | USA | 3 |
 Tajon Buchanan | Canadá | 3 |
 Cecilio Waterman | Panamá | 3 |
| Aníbal Godoy | Panamá | 2 |
| Alexis Vega | México | 2 |
  Jairo Henríquez | Salvador | 2 |
| Atiba Hutchinson | Canadá | 2 |
| Tim Weah | USA | 2 |
  Celso Borges Mora | Costa Rica | 2 |
| Erick Davis | Panamá | 2 |
 Brayan Moya | Honduras | 2 |
 Henry Martín | América | 2 |
| Andre Gray | Jamaica | 2 |
 Bryan Ruiz González | Costa Rica | 2 |
 Anthony Contreras Enríquez | Guanacasteca | 2 |
 Joel Campbell | - | 2 |
 Shamar Nicholson | Jamaica | 2 |
| Uriel Antuna | Cruz Azul | 1 |
| Kevin López | Comunicaciones | 1 |
| Oniel Fisher | Jamaica | 1 |
| Juan Pablo Vargas | Costa Rica | 1 |
 Alexander López | Honduras | 1 |
| Junior Hoilett | Canadá | 1 |
| Azmahar Ariano | Panamá | 1 |
| Sergiño Dest | FC Barcelona | 1 |
| Samuel Adekugbe | Canadá | 1 |
| Gabriel Torres Tejada | Panamá | 1 |
| Alphonso Davies | Canadá | 1 |
| Nelson Bonilla | Salvador | 1 |
| Jesús Manuel Corona | México | 1 |
| Andrés Andrade | Panamá | 1 |
| Daniel Johnson | Jamaica | 1 |
| Orbelín Pineda | México | 1 |
| Edson Álvarez | México | 1 |
| Weston McKennie | USA | 1 |
| Eriq Zavaleta | Salvador | 1 |
| Alex Roldán | Salvador | 1 |
| Rogelio Funes Mori | México | 1 |
| Darwin Cerén | Salvador | 1 |
| Héctor Moreno | México | 1 |
| Kemar Roofe | Jamaica | 1 |
| Cristian David Gil Hurtado | Salvador | 1 |
| Alberth Elis | Honduras | 1 |
| Romell Quioto | Honduras | 1 |
| Paul Arriola | USA | 1 |
| Cesar Yanis | Panamá | 1 |
| Freddy Góndola | Panamá | 1 |
| Jorge Sánchez | América | 1 |
| Jesús Ferreira | USA | 1 |
| Sebastián Córdova | México | 1 |
| Óscar Duarte Gaitán | Saprissa | 1 |
| Gerson Torres Barrantes | - | 1 |
| Keysher Fuller Spence | Cartaginés | 1 |
| Jonathan Osorio | Canadá | 1 |
| Enrico Hernández | Salvador | 1 |
| Hirving Lozano | México | 1 |
